On the Edge of the Dark Sea of Darkness is the first in the four-part Wingfeather Series by Andrew Peterson. Amazon recommends it for children in third through seventh grades
The story takes place in the mythical land of Skree, which has been taken over by life-size lizard-like people called Fangs, whose leader is Gnag the Nameless.
The book’s main focus is the Igiby family: mother Nia, grandfather Podo, and children Janner, Tink, and Leeli. Podo is an old pirate with a pegleg, but he’s amazingly agile. Leeli’s leg is crooked, and she walks with a crutch. The children’s father died some time ago, and Janner is disturbed that his grandfather and mother won’t allow questions about him.
Despite the oppressive Fangs, life is fairly peaceful in Skree.
Oh, yes, the people of Skree were quite free, as long as they were in their homes by midnight. And as long as they bore no weapons, and they didn’t complain when their fellow Skreeans were occasionally taken away across the sea, never to be seen again. But other than the cruel Fangs and the constant threat of death and torture, there wasn’t much to fear in Skree (p. 3).
But then the children have an altercation with one of the Fangs, Slarb. The children are put in jail but released when their mother gives the commander some of her jewels.
But now they are on Slarb’s radar.
And Janner didn’t even know his mother had jewels. Between that and the secrets surrounding his father, Janner wonders what else his mother is hiding.
The tension escalates into a classic battle of good-vs.evil with a surprise revelation at the end.
Alongside this plot, the children have normal fusses with each other and learn to face fears.
There seems to be some symbolism or allusions to Christian themes like in the Chronicles of Narnia. The family prays to “the Maker.”
One GoodReads reviewer said “Peterson intended this to be the ‘vastness of Lord of the Rings’ with the ‘whimsey of the Princess Bride.'” I don’t know if she read that in an interview: if so, I’d love to find it. It does help understand the tone of the story.
Some of the animals that live in Skree and the nearby forest are skonks, toothy cows (like our cows except they have long fangs and are omnivores), thwaps–like squirrels, a menace to gardens, and flabbits–like rabbits bur hairless with exceptionally long ears..
The danger is real and scary, but humor is sprinkled throughout. In fact, there seemed too much humor in the first part of the book.
I had a hard time getting into the book at first. But once the action picked up and some of the things hinted at came to light, I thought it was very good.
Some of my favorite quotes:
Blood was shed that you three might breathe the good air of life, and if that means you have to miss out on a Zibzy game, then so be it. Part of being a man is putting others’ needs before your own (pp. 23-24),.
There’s just something about the way he sings. It makes me think of when it snows outside, and the fire is warm, and Podo is telling us a story while you’re cooking, and there’s no place I’d rather be–but for some reason I still feel… homesick (p. 70).
Even if hope is just a low ember at night, in the morning you can still start a fire.
An animated series has been made of the books–at least the first two, I think. I have not seen it but want to with my son’s family. It appears to be very well done.
(Sharing with Bookish Bliss)

I don’t know if I could get into a kid’s fantasy book — but I do love that you stretched yourself and this is an excellent review. Yes, it would be fun seeing the animated series with your son’s family!
C. S. Lewis has a quote to the effect that a book for children should be able to be enjoyed by adults, too. I’ve found that to be true with classics. I haven’t read too many modern children’s books since my kids have grown up. I knew this had the book series and animation and wanted to see if I would recommend it to my grandson. I think he’d like the animated series. I think some of the humor in the book might be hard for a child to grasp until he gets used to it.
Interesting! The reference to Lord of the Rings makes it sound even more interesting. The humor has got to come from The Princess Bride!
I always enjoy a good children’s book. Thank you for this review, Barbara.
Pingback: May Reflections | Stray Thoughts