Wildwood Creek is the fourth and final book in Lisa Wingate’s Shores of Moses Lake series. Unlike the others, this is a dual-timeline story.
In the 1850s, Bonnie Rose O’Brien and her family were captured by the Comanche. Her parents were killed, and Bonnie Rose and her younger sister, Maggie May, were held captive for years. Upon their deliverance, Bonnie feels soiled and shameful, even though nothing that happened to her was her fault. When the missionaries she’s staying with recommend her for a teaching position in the wilderness, she sees it as a chance to start over.
In 1861, a man named Harland Delavan is starting a new community called Wildwood to search for gold in Texas. He hires Bonnie as well as others to fill the town’s needs. But he rules with an iron hand. Soon individuals and then whole families disappear without explanation. Rumors and myths spread like wildfire, creating legends that linger through the centuries.
In 2014, Allie Kirkland is following in her father’s footsteps. He was a film director, and her earliest memories involve being with him on set. When he died, Allie’s life was never the same. Her mother remarried a lawyer, and they both urged Allie to work in his firm and major in law. Allie feels she doesn’t fit in with her step-siblings and half-siblings.
When Allie learns of a summer internship for a reality TV show, she jumps at the opportunity and is hired. A famous filmmaker wants to recreate the town of Wildwood near Moses Lake Texas, and have actors represent the townspeople and live as they did while exploring the mysteries of what could have happened to them.
Before long, mysterious things begin to happen in this Wildwood, too. Allie feels a kinship with the young teacher, Bonnie Rose. Can she find out what happened before it’s too late?
It was fun to see some of the characters from the previous books again. That’s one nice thing about reading a series one right after the other–I recognized people I might not have otherwise. I think there’s enough explanation in each book that they could be read alone, but they do build on each other.
Each of the Moses Lake books involves someone whose plans are upended in some way, causing them to reconnect with a faith they’ve neglected. Each story also contains some level of mystery and the importance of community.
Reading four books of one author in succession also brings to light an author’s quirks. I think in every book, someone is said to “flash an eye tooth” at someone. I’d never heard that phrase before–I suppose it’s an idiom for a wide grin.
I listened to the audiobook, which had two different women reading Bonnie Rose’s and Allie’s sections: Morgan Hallett and Heather O’Neill. Then I checked the ebook out via Libby to look at some passages there.
I think this book is the best of the four. My only disappointment is that I was looking forward to the author’s notes about her inspiration for this series and whether any of the details or characters were based in fact, yet there were none. At the end of the third book, the author says her husband, like one of the main characters there, got an unexpected job offer in a small Texas town. So I imagine many of the details of the Moses Lake community came from that experience. I did find a guest blog post from Lisa about the book here and an interview here.

I have this series of book on my TBR list for some future time. I’m not altogether fond of books that use dual time lines. I tend to have a hard time keeping things together. This one really sounds interesting though. I enjoy book series that follow characters through the series too.
I was curious about the “flash an eye tooth” expression and so googled it.
The phrase “flash an eyetooth” likely refers to a playful or exaggerated gesture of looking at someone with a bright, focused gaze, often used to draw attention or express interest.
Have a good week.
I had googled it, too, but the only response was in the “AI” section at the top–none of the other Google results were about the phrase. They just explained what an eye tooth was. 🙂 The AI response just said it was a grin or smile that revealed the eye teeth–which seemed to mean a pretty wide grin. I think there are better ways of saying that, though.
This book was pretty easy to keep the different timelines separate. With the audiobook, the different voices helped. But even in print, the name of the character, date, and location is shared at the beginning of each chapter.
Well yay for a series ending with possibly the best one yet! I too notice author quirks and the eyetooth thing is new to me too 🙂 I too like when there’s an author note giving more info; nice that you could find online interviews with the author!
Like Melanie, I’m not all that fond of dual-time stories either. So I was dragging my feet diving into this one. Thanks for the review and the overview of the storyline.
Pingback: August Reflections | Stray Thoughts
Well done on finishing the series! It is interesting to think about the things we pick up as we read!Thanks for sharing this review with the Historical Fiction Reading Challenge.