Anne of Green Gables: The Sequel

L. M. Montgomery Reading Challenge Carrie’s Lucy Maud Montgomery Reading Challenge, includes any of the films based on LMM’s books as well as the books themselves. I’ve read Anne of Avonlea, Anne of the Island and  Anne of Windy Poplars (linked to my reviews) for this challenge, and I wanted to rewatch Anne of Green Gables: The Sequel at this time because it covers all three books. I had watched it (originally titled Anne of Avonlea on VHS) when it was first shown on PBS years ago.

“Covers” is not the right verb: it’s kind of a mash-up.

Anne of Avonlea deals with Anne’s first two years of teaching in Avonlea school, Anne of the Island with her four years at college, and Anne of Windy Poplars with her years of being a principal at Summerside High School (Kingsport Ladies’ College in the film) while Gilbert is in medical school.

The film begins at the end of Anne’s years of teaching in Avonlea. It leaves out completely Anne’s years at Redmond College and her almost-fiance from that time, Royal Gardiner, but it projects that relationship onto a father of one of Anne’s students at Kingsport. The Harris family is an amalgam of several different people from the books. In the books Anne and Gilbert are engaged at the end of Anne of the Island and then Anne teaches for three years while he finishes medical school, but the film has Anne leaving Avonlea to teach partly to get away from Gilbert’s pursuits and ends with their engagement after only one year of Anne’s being at Kinsgport.

Despite the jumble of plots and characters, many of the lines from the film are verbatim from the books, though some are said by different characters and in different settings. I think much of the spirit of the books is captured, from Anne’s feeling out of place and regretting everyone’s growing up and changing in Anne of the Island and her spirit in Anne of Windy Poplars. Her winning over of the snobbish Pringle family happens differently in the film than the book, but many of the elements are there. “Katherine with a K” with all her “prickles and stings” is portrayed excellently — I could feel and sympathize with the stark bleakness she saw her life to be. Her “transformation” was taken a bit father and faster than portrayed in the books.

I do have mixed emotions about the film. I loved seeing the characters come to life, the beautiful scenery, the lace on even the most severe characters, the old-fashioned pins and brooches (when these films first came out, many I knew dressed, not just like the films, but using many elements from them. I still love old-fashioned lace and brooches. I wish people still wore hats like the ones there!) I can understand the mash-up better than I can the atrocity that was done in Anne of Green Gables: The Continuing Story. I think the film could have worked covering the sequence of events as they were in the books, but even some dedicated Anne fans feel that the Island and especially Windy Poplars lag a little bit, so, again, I can understand why the film was done this way, despite my purist preferences. I did miss Anne’s “House O’ Dreams” with her college chums and china dogs amd Aunt Jamesina as well as Rebecca Dew and some other characters from the books. But the film was a very enjoyable way to spend a couple of evenings, and I am sure I’ll watch it again and again in years to come.

9 thoughts on “Anne of Green Gables: The Sequel

  1. I am a purist, so I share your sentiments in many ways. The “Continuing Story” was an affront to my sensibilities. Anne…is into espionage? Really? Ugh.

    The first two films were a delight to watch, perfectly cast, glorious cinematography. We’ve seen Megan Follows in a couple other things, but I think I prefer to have her retained as the precocious Anne in my memory. 🙂

  2. I’ve so enjoyed reading your take on things this month! It’s been so fun to interact on all of this stuff with you.

    I like the 1910 fashions. I think it would be great fun to wear those dresses again and, yes, the hats too. (Although I can’t say I have much of a head for hats! I do think they are rather fun and charming on the right people!)

    Calling this movie a “mash” is just about right! Amen to Diane’s comment. Both comments! (I can’t watch Megan Follows as anything else either.)

  3. My daughter has a set of those books and when she was having her first baby about 4 years ago, I began reading them. I do not recall which book I got up to, but I found I couldn’t just keep reading them. I think there is 8 and I may have read 7? I just had to stop for a while and I do not know if I ever finished the series!

  4. Pingback: Lucy Maud Montgomery Reading Challenge Wrap-up « Stray Thoughts

  5. I’ve enjoyed the first two movies (we own them both), even though they don’t follow exactly. Like you, I think they really do capture the “spirit” of the books. All the main characters are just nearly spot-on with what I imagined from the books. I haven’t been able to bring myself to ever watch the third movie. I just don’t understand why they went that way with it, but since it bears no resemblance to the books, I just don’t even want to see it.

I love hearing from you. I've had to turn on comment moderation. Comments will appear here after I see and approve them.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.