I discovered this book on my shelves while looking for another Narnia-related book. I don’t remember where and when I bought it or whether I ever read it to the children (I’ll have to ask them if they remember it). I didn’t remember it at all until after I read it through again.
Even though the Amazon listing calls this book a graphic novel, the book itself doesn’t have that designation anywhere on it. Perhaps they added that onto it later to make it current and trendy? I don’t know.
It is bound like a book but the illustrations, though not what I would call comic-bookish themselves, are laid out in something of a comic book or graphic novel style. I tried to get a few examples: Please forgive my fingertips in the pictures trying to hold the book open.
The book is abridged and illustrated by Robin Lawrie and was published in 1993. It appears to be out of print though I did find used copies on the Amazon and B&N sites.
I thought the illustrations themselves were lovely and far above what we think of as a comic book style. And I appreciated that many passages were straight from the books though of course many parts were summarized and several scenes left out at the book is only 64 pages.
To many of us the thought that our beloved classic fairy tale has been reduced to a graphic novel invokes an initial reaction of horror. But we wouldn’t have the same reaction if it were called an abridged illustrated children’s version, which it could be called in one sense. Graphic novels seem to have a connotation of luridness about them though I don’t know if they truly are: my boys read a few when they were younger but were never obsessed by them, and the ones we read were fine though one shop that sold them was creepy. Too, I have no objection to good books being translated into this style for those who do read them. If there are people who only read graphic novels, why not give them a good choice of material?
Though I’d rather read to my children or have them read the full book version for all its richness, if I had one who didn’t particularly enjoy reading or was into graphic novels, I wouldn’t hesitate to let them read this version.
I do wrestle with whether I would use something like this to introduce the books. (My boys are older now so it is a moot question until grandkids come along except for philosophizing). I think I’d still rather have them read the books first and then show them something like this afterward, but I can picture letting a small child look through this while the rest of the family read the books out loud. Knowing the story, I enjoyed looking through this summary and the illustrations.
(This review will also be linked to Semicolon‘s Saturday Review of Books.)
Wow , that is so pretty. It would be nice to have it for the illustrations alone and use it with the full edition to read to kids!
I just ordered a copy 😉
OH yes…. I DID see a copy of this once at our local used bookstore and bypassed it. I’ve been kicking myself ever since. I just didn’t like the layout at the time, and I’m not convinced I totally would even now. However, I do find it curious.
I dislike abridged copies of what I consider “easy reads” but once you know the story I’m wondering more about it. Anyway, I wish I had picked it up for the illustrations alone now!
Pingback: Narnia Reading Challenge Wrap-up « Stray Thoughts
Just reading the pages you’ve shown here, I can see that this “graphic novel” version does quote the book directly quite a bit–which already puts it up there in my estimation. In general, I’m not fond of abridgments of books that are already easy (and good) in the first place. This one, though, looks like it might be an exception (although I am as equivocal as you about whether to use such books to introduce a reader–what if they don’t like it because it’s been dumbed-down and then refuse to read the real thing? what if they get too attached to the dumbed-down version and it sours their taste for the real thing?)
Pingback: Books Read in 2011 « Stray Thoughts
Pingback: Chronicles of Narnia Reading Challenge « Stray Thoughts
Pingback: Book Review: The Horse and His Boy « Stray Thoughts
Pingback: Book Review: The Last Battle | Stray Thoughts